

Bay Lake Tower vs. Kidani Village: Which DVC Rental is Best via David’s?
So you’ve been researching renting DVC points. You know that you want a Deluxe Disney stay without the $700+ per night price tag. First of all, congrats! You have made the important discovery that there is a better way to do Disney World. You don’t have to pay high prices directly through their site. Let me give you our perspective as a family of four who have stayed at both sleek, Bay Lake Tower and the immersive, animal-filled escape of Kidani Village at Animal Kingdom Lodge.
To preface this, I will say that if your family is a go, go, go type and loves to be near the action of Magic Kingdom, then you’ll want to read what I have to say about our Bay Lake Tower stay. On the other hand, if you are looking for a stay that is more about rest and rejuvenation, as well as the awesome animal and nature aspect, you’ll want to take a look at our Kidani Village details.
Full Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links for David’s Vacation Club Rentals, a service my family has personally used and trusted since 2017. If you book through my link, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you, which helps me keep Liner Latitude running. Thank you for supporting my small business!


How Renting Through David’s Works: A Step-by-Step Guide
If you’re like me and do extensive research before every family vacation, the idea of renting points can feel a bit like a too good to be true Disney secret. Having used David’s Vacation Club Rentals since 2017, I can tell you it’s the most straightforward way to stay in a Deluxe Villa.
Here is how the process works from start to finish:
The Intermediary Advantage: David’s acts as a professional bridge between you and actual DVC members. While I’ve compared them to other sites over the last 10 years, I always come back to David’s. They are Disney experts, and always have lightning-fast communication.
Check Availability: You start by using their Cost Calculator to see exactly how many points your stay requires and the total price.
The Request Form: You submit a formal request with your preferred dates and resorts (like Bay Lake Tower or Kidani Village). You’ll pay a partial deposit at this stage, which is fully refundable if they can’t find a match for your stay.
The Match & Secure Payment: David’s works their magic to find a member with the right points. Once matched, they secure your reservation and you pay the remaining balance.
Instant Integration: This is my favorite part—once your reservation is confirmed, David’s sends you a Disney Confirmation Number.
Link Directly to Disney: You take that confirmation number and plug it straight into the My Disney Experience app. It links immediately, allowing you to book dining, see your plans, and even use your MagicBands just like a regular hotel guest.
Room Breakdown: Bay Lake Tower vs. Kidani Village

- Bay Lake Tower: During our stay at Bay Lake Tower, we booked a Resort View that turned out to be the perfect transportation hub for the eyes. We were positioned facing the Contemporary, which meant we could watch the monorail glide through the building, while the other side of our balcony offered a fantastic view of the lake and the Seven Seas Lagoon boats. The kitchenette was a lifesaver—perfect for storing and prepping our Instacart grocery order. But let’s be honest: the absolute X-factor and major selling point for any mom with young kids is that you are just steps from Magic Kingdom. While the Contemporary’s ultra-modern style isn’t for everyone, you simply cannot beat that proximity. As a whimsical bonus, we could hear and see the Electrical Water Pageant from our room at night. It’s a “love it or hate it” Disney classic, but I find myself drawn to the nostalgia and whimsy of it every time!
Planning a Disney getaway but can’t decide between the theme parks and the high seas? We did a deep-dive comparison to see which experience actually offers the best value, less stress, and more magic for families this year. Check out our full breakdown here: Disney World vs. Disney Cruise Line: Which is Actually Better for Your Family?


- Kidani Village: When you book a stay at Kidani Village through David’s Vacation Club Rentals, prepare to be transported to the heart of an African safari. There is truly nothing like the awe-inspiring moment of waking up, stepping onto your balcony, and seeing giraffes and zebras wandering just feet away. Beyond the animals, the resort itself is a standout. The legendary Indian-style Bread Service at Sanaa lived up to the hype—it’s a must-order appetizer. For our kids, Samawati Springs Pool was the highlight; the mix of a thrilling long slide and a gentle “short slide” was perfect for our daughter when she was younger. The one trade-off is the location. Unless you’re heading to Animal Kingdom (which is minutes away), you’ll spend a bit more time on the Disney buses compared to the monorail resorts. Since our family gravitates toward Magic Kingdom and EPCOT, the commute is something we have to weigh—but I truly believe every Disney fan needs to experience the magic of Animal Kingdom Lodge at least once!
The Point Breakdown: Getting More for Your Money
When you look at the David’s Vacation Club cost calculator, the price difference between these two resorts becomes clear pretty quickly. Generally, Kidani Village costs fewer points per night than Bay Lake Tower, making it one of the best values in the DVC system.


Because Bay Lake Tower sits on premier real estate next to Magic Kingdom, you pay a premium for that walking path. At Kidani Village, those same points often stretch much further. For our family, this meant we could often book a 1-Bedroom Villa at Kidani for a similar price to a Studio at Bay Lake Tower.
In the DVC world, that point gap is the difference between having a kitchenette and a full kitchen—or in the case of Kidani, gaining that legendary second bathroom in the 1-bedroom units. If you are looking to extend your vacation by a few extra nights or simply want more square footage for your kids to spread out, Kidani Village is almost always the winner for your wallet.
Planning a cruise? Read up on my list of 7 banned items on cruises. See what we brought that got confiscated and we never saw it again!
Final Verdict
- Choose Bay Lake Tower if: You have young kids, love Magic Kingdom, and value every minute of park time.
- Choose Kidani Village if: You want more space (that 2nd bathroom!), a slower pace, and a resort that is an experience in itself.
Still can’t decide? I know choosing between these two iconic resorts is a tough call. If you’re leaning toward the convenience of Bay Lake Tower or the immersive theme of Kidani Village, my best advice is to check the David’s Cost Calculator to see the price difference for your specific dates. Sometimes the savings on one over the other makes the decision for you! Have you stayed at either of these? Share your experience in the comments!